Governing law and jurisdiction clauses: where disputes will be heard

Governing law and jurisdiction
Governing law and jurisdiction

Quick answer: The governing law clause says which country's law interprets the contract; the jurisdiction clause says which courts hear disputes. Between Indian parties, the law is Indian law, and an "exclusive jurisdiction" clause choosing one of the courts that would otherwise have jurisdiction is generally valid. If the contract has an arbitration clause, the seat of arbitration usually decides which courts supervise it.

These clauses sit at the end of the contract, but they can decide whether a dispute costs a little or a lot.

Governing law

For contracts between Indian parties, Indian law applies. In cross-border contracts, parties can usually choose the law, and courts generally respect the choice. Pick a law your business and lawyers understand.

Jurisdiction

Under the Code of Civil Procedure, more than one court may have jurisdiction: where the defendant is, and where the cause of action arose. A jurisdiction clause narrows this down.

Is an exclusive jurisdiction clause valid?

Section 28 of the Indian Contract Act makes void agreements that absolutely restrict a party from enforcing its rights in the usual legal tribunals. The Supreme Court has held that parties can agree to submit to one of the courts that already has jurisdiction, and that clauses using words like "exclusive" or "only" exclude the others. A clause choosing a court with no connection to the contract at all doesn't create jurisdiction.

How does arbitration change things?

If the contract has an arbitration clause, the dispute goes to arbitration, and the courts at the seat of arbitration supervise it (appointments, interim measures, challenges). Make sure the jurisdiction clause and the seat point to the same city. See [arbitration clauses](/blog/arbitration-clause-in-contracts-seat-and-venue).

What should a business choose?

• The city where you are based, if you can.
• One clear court, using "exclusive".
• Consistency with the arbitration seat.
• For cross-border deals, think about where you'd need to enforce a judgment or award.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between governing law and jurisdiction?

Governing law is which law interprets the contract; jurisdiction is which courts can hear disputes about it.

Can parties choose any court in India?

They can choose among courts that already have jurisdiction (for example, where a party is located or the contract was performed). They can't give jurisdiction to a court that has none.

Do I need a jurisdiction clause if there's an arbitration clause?

It still helps, to name the courts for supervisory matters, but it should match the arbitration seat.

Spot mismatches fast

April's [review](/features/review) shows the governing law, jurisdiction and dispute resolution clauses together, so mismatches stand out.

This article is general information, not legal advice.